20 Best electric versus gas pool heater

Many homeowners wonder which type of pool heater is best. Some would even say that they prefer one over the other. It has been said that an electric versus gas pool heater is better than a combination of the two. However, there are several things that a homeowner should keep in mind before deciding on which one they would want to use.

Discount !!!
Gas Patio Heater with Wheels And Cover,48,000 BTU of Outdoor Portable LP Propane Commercial Heater ,automatically shuts off gas flow ,with CSA Certified for Garden
  • 1.Powerful Outside Heater with cover:48,000 Btu Burner Heats Up To 200 Sq Ft,This Propane Patio Heater Is Suitable For Both Commercial And Household Use.
  • 2.Safe& Reliable Heater with cover:Valve Automatically Shuts Off When Gas Leaking.Gas Auto Shut-Down When The Heater Tilting Over. 20-Lb Standard Propane Tank House (Tank Not Included) A Pefect Alternative To A Fire Pit,Provide Quiet And Smooth Heat, Without Smoke Or Flame-Up.Variable-Heat Control Knob Allows To Adjust The Flame .
  • 3.Easily Accessible Outdoor Propane Heater:Electronic Ignition To Quick And Easy Starts In 3 Seconds. Assembly This Floor Standing Heater Is Equipped With Heavy-Duty Smooth Wheels Which Allows Easy Movement.We Have Stable Weight Plate, No Need To Nail On The Ground.
  • 4.Easily-assemble Heater:Assembly Required With Wrenth,Magnetic Head Phillips Screwdriver (Not Included),By Following The Instructions In 30 Minute
  • 5.Good Quality Heater with cover:Outdoor Heaters For Patio Uses Heat Treated Stainless Steel For Strength And Durability,And CSA Certified. 1-Year Limited Warranty.
OUTERDO Immersion Water Heater,Electric Submersible Immersion Water Portable Heater with Stainless-Steel Guard and Digital LCD Thermometer,Great for Bathtub,Inflatable Pool,Fully Immersed While Using
157 Reviews
OUTERDO Immersion Water Heater,Electric Submersible Immersion Water Portable Heater with Stainless-Steel Guard and Digital LCD Thermometer,Great for Bathtub,Inflatable Pool,Fully Immersed While Using
  • ✔ 【Heating Water in Minutes】Submersible electric heater makes water heating more efficiency and boil 5 gallon of the water in minutes, all you need to do is just put the heater in to the water then connect the 120V power supply, easy to use.
  • ✔ 【Easy to Use】Place immersion heater for water in a container designed to contain boiling water, fill the container with water to full cover the submersible bucket heater shield(including stainless-steel guard and plastic part), plug portable water heater into a properly grounded 120V AC outlet, make sure the portable immersion heater is on, Feel the difference in a few minutes!
  • ✔ 【Warning】①The heater needs to be completely immersed in water in working condition②Do not use it for more than 3 hours continuously! ③Please do not plug the two heaters into the same outlet to avoid fire hazards. ④Please take out the heater before touching the water!
  • ✔ 【High Quality & Safety】With high quality stainless-steel protect cover,submersible water heater will effectively prevent the heating element is in direct contact with people or animals and heat dissipates to the water faster by flowing through the holes in the guard.We select the high performance heating element which has been strictly tested to ensure the superior quality, durable and reusable.
  • ✔ 【Widely Application】The Immersion Water Heater can be used in different size container like bucket, basin, bath tub, mini inflatable swimming pool, etc.Unlike the common bucket heater, in appearance, this water heater is lighter and smaller,making it perfect for travels and road trips.
Kokido Keops Solar Dome Above Ground Swimming Pool Water Heater | K835CBX/RV
  • Don't let summer's end keep you from swimming, this Kokido Keops Solar Dome Above Ground Pool Water Heater lets you swim on into the cooler months of the year
  • Extend your swimming season with warm water and heat your pool to a warm, comfortable temperature
  • Environmentally friendly heating energy
  • Dramatically reduces or eliminates pool heating costs compared with gas or electrical heater
  • Includes a protective cover for storage purpose when not in use
48,000 BTUs Outdoor Heaters for Patio Propane, Terra Hiker Outdoor Patio Heater with Wheels, Stainless Steel Propane Space Heaters, Garden Gas Heater with ETL Certified Safety Ignition System
  • UP TO 48000 BTUs HEAT FOR WARMING YOUR ENTIRE BODY: A 20 lb standard propane tank burns for up to 12 hours, allowing you to enjoy the pleasure of chatting, singing, barbecuing with friends, or playing with your puppy for longer periods; an aluminum reflector generates instant, concentrated heat in a large area of up to 269 sq. ft., making your whole body warm in 3 minutes
  • DURABLE & INSTANT IGNITION SYSTEM: Featuring a piezo ignition system that supports a lifespan of up to 10,000 uses; igniting the outdoor heater patio is a breeze, creating an instant flame by simply turning the control knob and pushing the igniter button; once ignited, instant heat is output for you without having to wait in the cold
  • EASY INSTALLATION & GREAT STABILITY: Outdoor propane heater can be easily assembled by 2 adults in about 30 minutes; a wheel assembly allows for effortless transport; with just a screwdriver, anyone can install patio heater propane with ease; a robust base will make the heater more stable after the gas tank is placed inside
  • SAFETY & RUST RESISTANCE: Approved by both the CSA and CE; a safety shut-off tilt valve will automatically turn off the outdoor propane heater if it gets tipped over; measuring 90 inches tall, the burner is situated high above the reach of any child or adult, helping avoid any accidental contact or burns; a stainless steel burner prevents melting or burning, so there is no need to worry about it rusting over time
  • GREAT FOR ANY OCCASION: The outdoor patio heater is ideal for commercial and home use, such as in a garden, on a residential patio, or outside a restaurant or bar on cold winter days; enjoy the fresh air outside while keeping warm and cozy; please note that the top and sides should have a safety clearance of 3 feet
Mr. Heater 30,000 BTU Vent Free Blue Flame Natural Gas Heater MHVFB30NGT
  • 30,000 BTU Natural Gas heater to heat spaces up to 1000 square feet
  • Blue flame burner for even convection heat. Maximum Elevation (Ft)-4500. Fuel Consumption/Burn Rate (Gal/Hr)- .030 MCF
  • Automatic low oxygen shut-off system (ODS). CSA Certified
  • Operating this heater at altitudes over 4,500 FT above sea level could cause pilot/ODS to shutdown the heater.included.Theromostat, legs and wall mounting hardware
  • Fuel Type:Natural Gas.Not for use in bathrooms, bedrooms, or recreational vehicles
Swimables Igniter with Gasket Kit Replacement for Pentair MasterTemp/Max-E-Therm Pool and Spa Heater 77707-0054
  • 🌊 MADE TO WORK WITH SELECT PENTAIR HEATER MODELS: The Igniter with Gasket Kit is compatible with Pentair MasterTemp Heaters and Sta-Rite Max-E-Therm Heaters
  • 🏊 IDENTIFYING THE PROBLEM: Open up your Pentair Mastertemp or Starite Maxetherm Heater and locate the Igniter. The igniter can be found via the heater's back access pane. There are two things that could be wrong with the igniter, first being shattered and second being burned.
  • 🛡️ INSTALL WITH EASE: After making sure the Pentair Igniter is damaged, proceed to changing them out. The igniter is held in by two screws. Take off the housing and replace the part. If you see rust, clean it up before replacing the part.
  • 💰 EXCEPTIONAL QUALITY: These aftermarket replacement parts for the Pentair Heaters are made by Swimables and are of the same or better quality compared to the originals parts. They are made to last in any weather condition.
  • ☑️ 100% SATISFACTION GUARANTEE: Buy with confidence, as our premium quality Pentair Heater Igniter Replacement is built to last, and if you're not satisfied with it at any time within 30 days of purchase, we'll provide a refund or replacement.
Discount !!!
SunHeater S120U Universal Solar Pool Heater 2 by 20-Feet, Black
  • Simple DIY installation; for in ground or above ground pools
  • Installs on roof, rack, ground or fence
  • Patented web design for maximum exposure to sun's rays
  • Uses existing pool pump
  • Raises pool water temperature 6-10 degrees F
Intex 28685E Solar Mat Above Ground Swimming Pool Water Heater for 8,000 GPH Pool, Black (2 Pack)
  • HEATS UP POOL: Increases temperature of the pool water by approx. 5°- 9° F depending on weather condition
  • SUITABLE/COMPATIBLE WITH: Suitable for above ground pools up to 8000 gal; Compatible with filter pump up to 1/2 hp or pump flow rate < 2500 gal/hr
  • ECO-FRIENDLY: Easy and economical to use with eco-friendly solar technology
  • DIMENSIONS: 47.25 x 47.25 inches; Weight: 6 lbs.
  • INCLUDED: Two adaptors B for 1 1/2" (38mm) hose connection, One 1/4 " hose attachment points, Bypass valve; Simple hook up; Quantity 2
Poolmaster 59026 Heater Slim Line Above-Ground Solar Power Swimming Pool Water Heat, 43” Long x 27” Wide, Black
  • Power Source Type: Solar Powered
  • Country Of Origin: China
  • Model Number: 59026
  • Item Package Dimension: 5.01" L x 2.63" W x 2.63" H
Discount !!!
Smart Pool S601 Pool Solar Heaters, Pack of 1, Black
  • Keep your pool warm with a polypropylene heat collector. Direct Flow System - One Header Hole for Each Heating Tube
  • Solar heater features 80 square feet of solar panels
  • Pool accessory is perfect for heating any in-ground swimming pool
  • Panel array measures 4 feet wide x 20 feet long. Raises Pool Water Temperature 6-10°F (4-6°C)
  • Installation kit required (Sold Separately)
Hayward W3H400FDP Universal H-Series 400,000 BTU Pool and Spa Heater, Propane
  • The Hayward Universal H-Series 400,000 BTU Propane Heater delivers premium heating performance for years of reliable, long-lasting comfort
  • A durable cupro nickel heat exchanger offers exceptional protection against corrosion and premature failure caused by unbalanced water chemistry
  • Industry-leading hydraulic design reduces circulation pump run time to provide major energy savings
  • Front-panel-only access and intuitive control pad provide easy operation, service and maintenance
  • Low NOx emissions meet air quality standards in all low-NOx areas, ensuring low environmental impact
SunHeater Pool Heating System Two 2’ x 20’ Panels – Solar Heater for Inground and Aboveground Made of Durable Polypropylene, Raises Temperature, 6-10°F, S240U
  • SOLAR POOL HEATER – The SunHeater Solar Pool Heating System allows you to capture free heat from the sun’s rays to effectively raise your pool water temperature. It’s an efficient and cost-effective method to heat your pool.
  • EXTENDS POOL SEASON – Your pool’s pump pushes the water through the panel’s many tubes where it’s warmed by the sun and then returned into the pool. This system can raise the water temperature 6-10 degrees F and extend your pool season by weeks!
  • EASY TO INSTALL – This pool solar heater uses your existing filtration system and has 4 end caps, 2 elbows for flex hose connection, 6 stainless steel hose clamps, 1 roll of Teflon tape, and rubber connector hoses.
  • TUBE ON WEB DESIGN – The tube-web-tube design allows the SunHeater to capture the most sun possible, maximizing square footage. It offers rigid flexibility, allowing panels to expand and contract with changing temps, giving it the strength needed to last.
  • DIMENSIONS – The SunHeater Solar Pool Heater includes two 2’ x 20’ panels, made of durable polypropylene. It’s a universal system that works for pools up to 31’ round or 18’ x 36’.
Immersion Water Heater, Bucket Water Heater, Submersible Water Heater 304 Stainless Steel Guard, Pool Heaters for Above Ground Pools To Heat 5 Gallons Water In Minutes(Black)
  • ❶Good Quality Portable Water Heater : Ding Ding immersion water heater runs with energy-saving .Imersion heater boils 5 gallon water in minutes . All you need to do is just put bucket heater in to the water and plug the pool warmer, easy to use.☘
  • ❷304 Stainless-steel Guard - The heavy duty 304 stainless-steel guard on the electric bucket heater protects the heating element from directly contacting persons or animals. The holes on the guard of submersible water heater help release heat into the water faster.☘
  • ❸Easy to Use:Place camping water heater into water designed to contain boiling water, fill the container with water to full cover the submersible bucket heater , plug portable water heater into a properly grounded 120V AC outlet, make sure the portable immersion heater is on, make the pool warmer in a few minutes!☘
  • ❹Very Wide Use:The electric immersion heater can be used in water,pool heaters for above ground pools fit for bucket, basin, bath tub, mini inflatable swimming pool, etc.This immersion heater is handy and super lightweight, making it pool warmer any grounded wall outlet. Then the 1500 immersion heater can start working.☘
  • ❺Warning :The camping water heater needs to be completely immersed in water ,Please do not plug the two camping water heater into the same outlet to avoid fire hazards. Please take out the immersion water heater before touching the water!☘
GAME 4721-BB SolarPRO Curve Solar Pool Heater, Made for Intex & Bestway Above-Ground and Inground Pools, Includes Intex Adapters, 2 Hoses & Clamps
  • SOLAR POOL HEATER: The GAME SolarPRO Curve Solar Pool Heater has been designed for above-ground and most inground pools. It increases the pool temperature by 5 degrees in 4 days (for an 8,000-gallon pool).
  • DURABLE CONSTRUCTION: We’ve designed this above-ground solar pool heater with high-quality materials that will hold up against frequent exposure to the sun and outdoor elements.
  • UNIQUE CURVED SHAPE: The GAME solar pool heater has been engineered with a unique curved shape that maximizes heat collection. The treaded ports have been added for versatile plumbing options.
  • ADJUSTABLE LEGS: This solar heater is compatible with Intex, Bestways, and most above and inground pools. The adjustable and foldable legs allow the heater to be set for maximum exposure to the sun, along with a clear cover that locks in heat.
  • THE PERFECT GRADUAL HEATER: This solar pool heater is not intended to be a miracle-cure heater. It’s designed to extend your pool season by gradually increasing the water temperature by a few degrees. Maximum heat output with space saving footprint
Allied Precision The Premier Line 742G Bucket Water Heater, Electric Immersion Heating Element Heats 5 Gallons of Water in Minutes with Auto Shutoff, Submersible Design is Heavy Duty and Portable 120V
  • HEAT 5 GALLONS OF WATER IN JUST MINUTES. Drop the portable bucket heater into water and it automatically starts working. While immersed, it will heat continuously past 150 degrees F and towards boiling, depending on the volume of the water and the container's insulation.
  • AUTOMATICALLY SHUTS OFF TO PREVENT OVERHEATING. Thermostatically controlled immersion water heater, means it automatically turns on and off as needed to maintain water temp. It will not overheat and saves power when not needed. Use for cold weather and travel.
  • LARGE DESIGN FITS PERFECTLY IN 5 GALLON BUCKET. Don't mess around with the smaller coil type submersible water heater products. The large size of the API Bucket Heater is designed to rest submerged in a 5 gallon bucket. Must be in 9" of water to work properly.
  • SAFE FOR USE IN ALL PAILS AND BUCKETS. Meets UL standards and is CSA listed. The stainless steel guard on the electric bucket heater protects the heating element from touching the bucket and prevents damage to the element itself. Won't melt plastic buckets.
  • EXTRA FEATURES DESIGNED TO GIVE YOU YEARS OF USE. Designed for heavy duty use. 6 foot power cord; 120v and 1000 watts; 3 prong plug. Used in many trades including masonry work, concrete work, wallpapering, agriculture, professional cleaning and more.
Black Outdoor Solar Dome Inground &Above Ground Swimming Pool Water Heater New
  • High Quality And Brand New. Solar Powered Swimming Pool Heater
  • Heat Your Pool In The Environmentally Friendly Way .No Electricity Or Gas Connections
  • Space Saving And Aesthetically Pleasing When Compared To Solar Panels .Extend Your Swimming Season With Warm Water And Heat Your Pool To A Warm, Comfortable Temperature
  • A Protective Cover Is Included To Protect The Dome When Not In Use .Connects To 1.5 Inch Hoses
  • Specifications Color: Black Material: PP, PC And PE Hose. Product Size: 22.4"X22.4"X8.7"(LXWXH) .Product Weight: 11.2lbs. Length Of Long Hose: 38.6". Length Of Short Hose: 14.5" .Package Include: 1 X Solar Dome , Swimming Pool Water Heater,
Sun2Solar Clear 18-Foot Round Solar Cover | 1600 Series | Heat Retaining Blanket for In-Ground and Above-Ground Round Swimming Pools | Use Sun to Heat Pool Water | Bubble-Side Facing Down in Pool
  • SAVE ON HEATING COSTS - Sun2Solar clear solar blankets are made from a film of thousands of tiny bubbles, which work together to collect and retain heat in your pool at night and on those chilly days. The clear color allows the sun’s UV rays to penetrate deeper into your swimming pool for warmer water temperatures. Pay less and swim more.
  • MINIMIZE WATER EVAPORATION - The use of a solar cover helps in preventing up to 95% of pool water evaporation. When not enjoying a refreshing swim, keeping your pool covered lessens the vast amount of water lost into the environment. Fill up your swimming pool less and enjoy it more!
  • HEAT RETENTION - After everyone has called it a day with wrinkled fingers from too much fun in the sun, make sure to place this solar cover back atop the water. Don’t lose all of that warmth generated throughout the day when the sun sets. Assure your pool’s temperature does not drop too much by protecting it at night through use of a solar blanket.
  • JUMP INTO WARMTH - Show friends and family your bravery by jumping in without the standard toe dip. Enter the swimming pool confidently knowing the Sun2Solar solar cover has kept the water warm just for you. It’s easy to put on and take off allowing more time for showing off.
  • TRIM TO FIT - Your pool may be uniquely shaped and getting the right fit is as easy as finding a marker and sharp pair of scissors. Have the bubbles facing down to the water and trace a line on the cover showing where you should cut off the additional material. Do so confidently knowing this won’t affect the manufacturer’s warranty---they understand.
sunCOIL - Solar Heater for Above Ground Pools with Free Diverter Valve Kit ($49.00 Value)
  • Ideal for above ground pools and soft sided Intex style pools; For larger pools or more heat more than one sunCOIL may easily be installed
  • FREE CONNECTION KIT and DIVERTER VALVE KIT (controls proper water flow through dome & allows water to bypass dome during pool vacuuming)
  • Clear Dome (performs like car windows in summer) and Black Coil help absorb sun's heat energy to transfer to your pool water
  • Folding Legs allow you to angle the sunCOIL toward the sun for best heating results
  • 5 year Warranty
ZMM 220V 240V 18KW Electric Pool Water Heater for Above Ground Inground Pool,Upgrade Portable SPA Water Bath Heater Thermostat Swimming Pool Thermostat Heater Pump
  • Note:It is 240V 18KW,only made for US.Connect The Wires Directly, Do Not Use Plugs.1.【316# stainless steel, Best in its class】
  • 2.【60,000 Btu/Hr heating capacity, 18KW】
  • 3.【Suitable for pools up to 5000 gallons in coastal climates】
  • 4.【Suitable for ALL Hot Tubs】
  • 5.【240 Volts 50A - 60 HZ American Voltage】
Raypak 336,000 BTU Digital Electronic Ignition Propane Pool Heater
  • 336,000 BTU propane digital pool and spa heater
  • Microprocessor-controlled thermostat can be set precisely to your liking , set it and forget it
  • Cabinet and the internals are non-corrosive and rust resistant
  • Features PolyTuf powder coating, polymer headers, and an all copper-fin-tube heat exchanger
  • Also features a stainless steel tube sheet, 2 inch CPVC water connections, burner tray and fire tile

What Is the Difference Between Gas and Electric Pool Heater?

The first consideration is price. There is no denying that gas powered heaters are more expensive than electric ones. However, if they are used only for heating the swimming pool and nothing else, it may not be worth the extra money to buy one. The majority of people who have a pool that they use as a hobby will use electric heaters because they are easier to install and operate.

Another thing that needs to be considered is how much electricity the pool heater will consume. If the pool is small, then an electric-powered heater may be all that is necessary. Otherwise, a combination of both types of heaters will be needed. It is also advisable to have a backup system in case the primary source of heat fails.

The pool heater that is used should be chosen based on its efficiency. An efficient heater consumes less energy, which means that it will save on electricity costs. However, certain models will cost more to run than they actually save. It is important to take this into account when choosing the one to buy. It is also a good idea to research the company that manufactures the heater.

The gas powered heaters are usually those that provide the most heat. These are generally more expensive than the electric-powered ones, but that extra cost is well worth it. Gas heaters also use a source that is cleaner than electricity. They do not create any by-products or pollution during operation, which is a major concern for those who worry about the environment. Most people are concerned about these issues, which is why many people are replacing their traditional wood-burning fireplaces with these energy-efficient heaters.

The disadvantage to using gas-powered heaters is that they can only be used when there is already an open flame. Some models require an open flame before they are able to heat up the water. This may not pose a problem for some individuals who have outdoor fires. Others, however, find that it does not always keep the water hot enough for them to swim. Gas heaters also pose a hazard to pets and children, as they may start a fire if they inadvertently touch the flames. This is a particular danger with gas heaters that are open flames.

An alternative to using gas to heat up the pool is electric. Many swimming pool owners opt for this choice because they are easier to install and operate. Electric pool heaters are also quieter than their gas-based counterparts, which is great for those who want to enjoy the ambiance of their pool without the noise of an on-site pool heater. This type of heater is a good choice for any residential or commercial swimming pool. They also do not pose a safety risk like that of gas heaters.

One of the most important factors in choosing an electric pool heater is determining what your budget is. Heaters range in price from about $500 for small portable heaters to several thousand dollars for huge commercial heaters. The size of the pool you have will also play a large part in your electric pool heater choice. Large electric heaters can easily heat a swimming pool three to four times larger than the pool’s footprint. Smaller electric heaters can easily heat a pool approximately the size of a standard swimming pool. This information should help you make an informed decision about what type of pool heater is best for your swimming pool.